Forums
First  << 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20 >>  Last
Forum Main>>Fun & Games>> Mafia 2 - Trouble at Bikini Bottom *Town Victory*
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
sam9000

ID: 1574059
Level: 30
Posts: 4724
Score: 2062
sam9000 [1574059]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 22:07:22
Some interesting observations you have so far.
By The_Reputed [68232]
Quite, but even as a concerned and innocent townie that doesn't need any attention whatsoever... i'm not much of a martyr so that strategy doesn't appeal to me. Not to mention burning through innocents doesn't seem too appealing to any decent person anyways where we're trying to flush out villians.

Who said anything about burning thru innocents? Is that whats on your mind?

Additionally, since there is no doctor, any special roles are designed for weeding out players, as it stands, the functionality is something like this:

3 players removed a day-
1 beneficial role for townies-
1 player good or bad can interfere with roles-

The Roleblocker is a good-aligned role.

Even if townies throw themselves out as cannon fodder, Spongebob could only review two players, the first of which has the possibility of already being dead. By then the numbers would look like this.

This comment reeks of disassociation. I would suspect a Townie would have phrased it "Even if we throw ourselves out as cannon fodder,..."

2 townies killed by plankton
2 townies lynched
2 townies mauled by Patrick

Why would you assume we don't lynch any Mafia? Are you expecting the vote to go a certain way?


7 townies remaining
2 good roles
1 Patrick
4 Plankton


No matter what happens at that point, even if Patrick or a plankton is identified, the game is already over as Plankton family can still make kills at a rate that leave them on top.

This is completely wrong. As long as we outnumber Mafia, we can win, especially if spongebob outs some of them.


No, We need to think critically about the situation and eliminate at least one killing player with the first day to have the odds in favor of the Bikini Bottom citizens.

Overstating the obvious to appear innocent and determined to the cause. Seems you've only been Mafia a couple hours and are already getting the hang of this.


I'll hold off on voting immediately since we do have some extended time and can only change votes once.

Change your vote as many times as you like. Kip won't mind.


One possible strategy is we propose to Spongebob the best candidate to inspect, this will at least give good intel, and depending on who responds, the more studious players will be able to determine who has a vested interest in this strategy...Unless you're all really good liars.

Perhaps you'd like to steer him to your Don to get him false cleared?

Unvote DB_farid

Vote The_Reputed




f74cc0f2-a98e-4799-82a4-ff0a261f2d76_zps
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
winick3

ID: 1617918
Level: 31
Posts: 232
Score: 89
C~Gwinick3 [1617918]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 22:13:55
im in

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 22:31:20
vote Sam9000
Sorry man, anyone who analyzes a post so thoroughly must be mafia, or not, either way I know how tricky you can be, better safe than sorry I always say. And for the record I'm gonna keep my eye on the_reputed aswell. The way I see it one of you is probably mafia and a straight across trade 1 townie for 1 mafia is a definite win in my book, that of a humble citizen of Bikini Bottoms.

Peace, Tchalla

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CandyCloud

ID: 1722403
Level: 17
Posts: 230
Score: 126
CandyCloud [1722403]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 22:38:00
so when we vote, how does it work? the person that get voted the most dies? what if 2 people end up getting the highest votes?

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 22:57:39
That's a good point, there isn't a judge anymore so does a tie result in no deaths? If so the mafia would have yet another advantage, they could vote in favor of tours and just weed us out during night phase

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
KipCurry

ID: 1709133
Level: 31
Posts: 490
Score: 418
KipCurry [1709133]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 23:12:54
The_Reputed, you can change your vote as much as you can during day phase.

If there is a tie, a new voting round happens with only the 2 or more players that are tied to vote for untill one gets more votes

memberof.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Fri Apr 19, 2013 23:29:12
Sounds good

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 00:00:24
So which one of you people is Patrick Star? Show yourself, you crazy killer!

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CaptQueeg

ID: 1689079
Level: 25
Posts: 2285
Score: 2023
CaptQueeg [1689079]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 00:14:01
The problem is, as Townies we don't see anything other than the lynching vote and then the victims from the night phase. We can monitor others activities (e-mails) but in the last game that was not very effective especially for people who have a lot of friends in the game and e-mail a lot. We have to rely on what people post in their e-mails and again, as found in the last game, it is hard to assess players who don't say very much. Anyone we lynch day #1 is pure chance and the odds are 25% that it will be the serial killer of the mafia. But to not lynch is stupid so we need to lynch. I am planning on looking at those who don't post much as likely suspects.

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 01:12:20
so..............if I were spongebob, and I'm not saying I am, but if I were.....

does that mean if I investigate someone and find out they are plankton I could message every single person and ask them to vote for that person because they are plankton and hope that that would work because even though the plankton would know my identity as spongebob it would at at least allow the town to lynch a plankton?

Or would spongebob only be allowed to message one person? And spongebob is the only one allowed to message all players, right? Plankton can only talk among themselves?

Last Edited: Sat Apr 20, 2013 01:13:12
4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 01:20:19
Spongebob will see plankton as a townie if he investigates him

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CandyCloud

ID: 1722403
Level: 17
Posts: 230
Score: 126
CandyCloud [1722403]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 01:44:37
i think so, according to the rules spongebobs could mail people but they cant respond back. and the plankton and his crew can mail among themselves.

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
S2K

ID: 179029
Level: 35
Posts: 1001
Score: 797
MYS2K [179029]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 01:46:58
Well, to be fair to sam9000, anyone can take great lengths to analyse a post, and it's even more so when The_Reputed left behind a name of deceit by associating himself with Rob Me Blind. Just gonna wait till everyone has their say before voting.

reward15_by_sweetblanca-d6ezxi4.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:08:27
This is true but I have an intolerance for long windedness in general haha

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:15:44
By Tchalla [1718784]
Spongebob will see plankton as a townie if he investigates him


I didn't mean plankton the boss...I meant one of the 3 cousins....someone spongebob can see as an enemy.

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CandyCloud

ID: 1722403
Level: 17
Posts: 230
Score: 126
CandyCloud [1722403]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:28:34
^ yea

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
sam9000

ID: 1574059
Level: 30
Posts: 4724
Score: 2062
sam9000 [1574059]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:38:18
By Tchalla [1718784]
This is true but I have an intolerance for long windedness in general haha


Well, like I told Kip already. I don't expect to survive for more than 2 nights. So, unfortunately it's gonna be fairly windy till Mafia does something about it. This was the 2nd time Tchalla attempted to stifle activity in town.

The 1st was much less subtle:
By Tchalla [1718784]
vote Sam9000
Sorry man, anyone who analyzes a post so thoroughly must be mafia, or not, either way I know how tricky you can be, better safe than sorry I always say.

Here, Tchalla attempts to condemn analyzation of speech(Currently our only means of detection). And then adds, its ok if I'm Town as long as I get lynched.

And for the record I'm gonna keep my eye on the_reputed aswell. The way I see it one of you is probably mafia and a straight across trade 1 townie for 1 mafia is a definite win in my book, that of a humble citizen of Bikini Bottoms.

Peace, Tchalla

A very nice token gesture. After you lynch a townie, you can attempt to disassociate yourself with Reputed because you'll "keep your eye on him." We'll all sleep better at night knowing that.



f74cc0f2-a98e-4799-82a4-ff0a261f2d76_zps
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CandyCloud

ID: 1722403
Level: 17
Posts: 230
Score: 126
CandyCloud [1722403]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:56:36
i have a question, does everyone have to vote? is it possible to abstain the vote without being disqualified?

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 02:59:34
Sam I'm really not trying to incriminate you, just a first vote based mainly from what I've gleamed from your play style from or first game, but I am flattered that you took the time to analyze my vote. I can assure you I am not in fact mafia, at this point I know that all the proof you have is my word so take it our leave it. But do you deny that a townie for a mafia is a bad deal? A this post becomes longer I realize that I have become quite long winded myself so I apologize for my previous statement I actually am enjoying this debate and I look forward to your response.

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:06:20
By CandyCloud [1722403]
i have a question, does everyone have to vote? is it possible to abstain the vote without being disqualified?


Votes are important. I don't think you should abstain. Just wait until the weekend is nearly over and keep your eye on the forum thread. It might give you a good idea how to vote.

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
sam9000

ID: 1574059
Level: 30
Posts: 4724
Score: 2062
sam9000 [1574059]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:12:13
Oh I'm having a blast, I love the game. I wish more people would get active though. I'm hoping its just because UK is asleep right now.

So, lets do this then. Right now, your obviously suspicious of myself, hence your vote. Who else are you suspicious of?

f74cc0f2-a98e-4799-82a4-ff0a261f2d76_zps
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
1718784
ID: 1718784
Level: 18
Posts: 1679
Score: 1072
1718784 [1718784]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:18:24
As of now you and reputed are the only ones that I have suspicions towards, granted I only have a few posts to go on but I side we shall see. Who else aside from me do you have a feeling about? Of course we have to wait and see what others to say so my vote could change at some point.

richard2_zpscc4b4faf.png
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
sam9000

ID: 1574059
Level: 30
Posts: 4724
Score: 2062
sam9000 [1574059]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:26:58
Right now I'm most suspicious of Tchalla, The_Reputed, and Daisy3.

Daisy, care to weigh in on your picks for the Gallows.

f74cc0f2-a98e-4799-82a4-ff0a261f2d76_zps
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CaptQueeg

ID: 1689079
Level: 25
Posts: 2285
Score: 2023
CaptQueeg [1689079]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:53:00
Well I am suspicious of 19 people even though only 5 of you are really bad. The only person we can really trust is the person that we lynch and if they are a Townie then we have a better chance to fins a mafia person the next time. I think the serial killer helps us (at least for a while) since he/she has the same chance of killing a mafia person (5/19) as we do. Of course, we both are more liekly to pick a townie than a bad person because of the numbers. Since no one knows anything yet, how can we convince each other of our innocene? (Captqueeg goes through the crowd giving everyone the secret handshake so they know he is a Townie) <<< would be nice huh.

So lets hear from more people and then vote - but again I am concerned about the UK contingent who vote as we US people are still sound asleep dreaming of serial killers and mafie.

Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Gheed

ID: 661744
Level: 33
Posts: 1916
Score: 1490
Gheed [661744]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:53:21
Vote sam9000
You can clearly see how he already thinks that 3 players are the mafia or bad guys. He's trying to make you concentrate on those players instead of him. He's trying to make you lynch them then make his move. I personally think that he's Patrick.

Lynch lynch lynch!!

1tsww3.jpg
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 03:58:57
By sam9000 [1574059]
Right now I'm most suspicious of Tchalla, The_Reputed, and Daisy3.

Daisy, care to weigh in on your picks for the Gallows.


sam, I have to admit I didn't think you were mafia/plankton at first...but now I wonder.

I have more feelings toward who might be townies (or beachies) then plankton at the moment. I'm going the weekend and hope more will get talking in the thread.

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 04:00:43
By Gheed [661744]
Vote sam9000
You can clearly see how he already thinks that 3 players are the mafia or bad guys. He's trying to make you concentrate on those players instead of him. He's trying to make you lynch them then make his move. I personally think that he's Patrick.

Lynch lynch lynch!!


EEEEK! SAM you better NOT be Patrick!!!!!!

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
sam9000

ID: 1574059
Level: 30
Posts: 4724
Score: 2062
sam9000 [1574059]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 04:02:57
By Daisy3 [730750]
By sam9000 [1574059]
Right now I'm most suspicious of Tchalla, The_Reputed, and Daisy3.

Daisy, care to weigh in on your picks for the Gallows.


sam, I have to admit I didn't think you were mafia/plankton at first...but now I wonder.

I have more feelings toward who might be townies (or beachies) then plankton at the moment. I'm going the weekend and hope more will get talking in the thread.


Very well, who do you think are townies then?



f74cc0f2-a98e-4799-82a4-ff0a261f2d76_zps
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
Daisy3

ID: 730750
Level: 72
Posts: 8543
Score: 5869
SoGDaisy3 [730750]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 04:09:01
I think candycloud and S2K are townies. I'm still watching the rest of you....lol
I kind of think Gheed is a townie too....he hasn't said much so its just a guess.

4b45d010-2d19-0f0c-730750.png
dangerous_by_sweetblanca-d6z0blj.gif
Super secret reinforced spam barrier 2.0
CandyCloud

ID: 1722403
Level: 17
Posts: 230
Score: 126
CandyCloud [1722403]Reply | Quote | Report

Posted on Sat Apr 20, 2013 04:10:35
By Daisy3 [730750]
I think candycloud and S2K are townies. I'm still watching the rest of you....lol
I kind of think Gheed is a townie too....he hasn't said much so its just a guess.


are you the police?

Last Edited: Sat Apr 20, 2013 04:11:21
Forum Main>>Fun & Games>> Mafia 2 - Trouble at Bikini Bottom *Town Victory*
First  << 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20 >>  Last